Copied to clipboard

Flag this post as spam?

This post will be reported to the moderators as potential spam to be looked at


  • Heather Floyd 610 posts 1033 karma points MVP 6x c-trib
    Nov 26, 2018 @ 23:36
    Heather Floyd
    2

    Discussion: Add a way to specify the "System" user account for programmatic Node actions (rather than User 0)?

    I have been thinking about the default use of "User Id = 0" for API node actions. For example, the ContentService's CreateContent() method.

    I wish there were a way to globally "override" the default user being User 0 (or, for V8, user -1). Why? Because when nodes are manipulated programmatically, I'd rather the "User" logged for that action to be one named "System" or something. By default, when you install Umbraco for a new project, the email address & password entered into the installation wizard is assigned to User 0. Generally, these credentials represent an actual human, who will likely be creating content in the CMS manually as a regular content editor.

    I just feel like for information and auditing purposes, it's more accurate/useful for automated programmatic actions to be assigned to a "System" user.

    In terms of implementation, it wouldn't be difficult to update the API methods which utilize a default User parameter to check a config file for a different user id to use.

    It could be added in such a way that if the site implementer doesn't create an alternative user and specify the new ID in the config file, the current default behavior of User 0 would be used.

    Any thoughts?

  • Søren Gregersen 441 posts 1884 karma points MVP 2x c-trib
    Nov 27, 2018 @ 00:38
    Søren Gregersen
    0

    The projects I’ve been on, we always start out by creating a “system” or “admin” user. A user that the developers use for creating doc types etc.

    Editors get their own users much later on.

    This way I don’t really get to the point you want to discuss :-)

  • Heather Floyd 610 posts 1033 karma points MVP 6x c-trib
    Nov 28, 2018 @ 17:01
    Heather Floyd
    0

    Hi Søren, Thanks for your response.

    Yes, sometimes I'm able to do that on new projects that I am setting up myself, but sometimes I am coming into an existing project, and someone else has set up the initial Umbraco installation.

    Also, with Umbraco Cloud, I believe that when you create a new site project, it will automatically be using your Umbraco Cloud portal account for the initial setup, which makes that trickier.

    I think the main issue is that at this point, once installation occurs, it's not possible to reassign "0" to a different user.

  • Shannon Deminick 1530 posts 5278 karma points MVP 3x
    Nov 27, 2018 @ 04:33
    Shannon Deminick
    0

    As a work around you could rename the admin user to System, then create any other admin accounts you wish, that way user 0 (or -1 in v8) is System, would that suffice?

  • Heather Floyd 610 posts 1033 karma points MVP 6x c-trib
    Nov 28, 2018 @ 17:10
    Heather Floyd
    0

    Hi Shannon,

    Nice to hear from you :-)

    Yes, technically, I could rename the user and create another account for the actual user I am replacing, but depending on how long the project has been running already, that means changing the audit history, etc. (If the original User 0 was a real person who created content nodes, etc. Now those nodes show that "System" created them, which isn't really true.)

    Perhaps this issue seems very persnickety... but I guess it just bugs me that something which isn't really changeable nor actually "significant" (IDs are just random numbers) is used for this. That's why I figured it would be nice to have the option to specify WHICH user Id should be used for all default Service operations (I know that in my own custom code I could code in a userId as a parameter, but that won't affect packages and add-ins which use the default behavior)

  • This forum is in read-only mode while we transition to the new forum.

    You can continue this topic on the new forum by tapping the "Continue discussion" link below.

Please Sign in or register to post replies