Hello all.

Still relatively new to Umbraco but having fun so far!

Having an issue when attempting to implement some custom validation into the membership section. I have created a method for Member.BeforeSave and have determined it successfully gets called by placing a log call in there.

The problem I am having however is that when I set the action to cancel it saves regardless. Even when including a call for an error speech bubble it simply shows the 'Member saved' bubble again.

I have used the exact same code for Document.BeforeSave and it works perfectly. No saving. My custom speech bubble shows.

Code below.

Many thanks.
J.

public class MemberValidation : ApplicationBase
{
    public MemberValidation()
    {
        Member.BeforeSave += new Member.SaveEventHandler(Member_BeforeSave);
    }

    void Member_BeforeSave(Member sender, SaveEventArgs e)
    {
        ((BasePage)HttpContext.Current.Handler).ClientTools.ShowSpeechBubble(BasePage.speechBubbleIcon.error, "Manual override", "This node was not saved, deal with it!");
        e.Cancel = true;
    }
}

public class NodeValidation : ApplicationBase
{
    public NodeValidation()
    {
        Document.BeforeSave += new Document.SaveEventHandler(Document_BeforeSave);
    }

    void Document_BeforeSave(Document sender, SaveEventArgs e)
    {
        ((BasePage)HttpContext.Current.Handler).ClientTools.ShowSpeechBubble(BasePage.speechBubbleIcon.error, "Manual override", "This node was not saved, deal with it!");
        e.Cancel = true;
    }
}