Sign in Register
Go to solution
Copied to clipboard

Flag this post as spam?

This post will be reported to the moderators as potential spam to be looked at


  • bengan 26 posts 90 karma points
    Oct 16, 2019 @ 12:09
    bengan
    0

    Issues in built-in URL-tracker (Redirect URL Management)?

    I just installed Umbraco 8.1.5 including the sample website. While testing a little bit (creating new pages, publishing, moving, renaming, deleting) I think that there is an issue in the "Redirect URL Management" (URL tracker) in the content section. Maybe my understanding of this feature is not right. If so, please let me know!

    When moving a published node there is no new redirect created. I expected the following redirect, but there is none (also checked the database table 'umbracoRedirectUrl').

    /* expected redirects (after moving) */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  /test-1/

/* existing redirects (after moving) */
<<none>>

    When moving back, still the same: no redirect is created.

    When renaming and publishing the node, a new redirect is created (as expected).

    /* Existing redirects (after renaming): */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  /about-us/test-2/

    When moving this node, the existing redirect is changed (as expected), but there is no new one created.

    /* Expected redirects (after renaming and moving): */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  /test-2/
/about-us/test-2/  -->  /test-2/

/* Existing redirects (after renaming and moving): */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  /test-2/

    When deleting a node, the existing redirect is changed (correct), but there is no new one created.

    /* Expected redirects (after renaming, moving and deleting): */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  #
/about-us/test-2/  -->  #
/test-2/           -->  #

/* Existing redirects (after renaming, moving and deleting): */
/about-us/test-1/  -->  #

    Furthermore, when requesting the "old" page link (/about-us/test-1/) in the browser, I get a 404. So there is no 301-redirect executed.

    Can you reproduce this behavior? Does this feature not work as it should? Or do I have wrong expectations? I also searched in the forum and in the web, but could not find anything (related to Umbraco 8.x)...

    Copy Link
  • Steve Megson 151 posts 1024 karma points MVP c-trib
    Oct 16, 2019 @ 13:31
    Steve Megson
    100

    You're right, there's a bug in the redirect tracking so it currently only records when nodes are renamed. It should also record nodes being moved, and it did in 7.x. Version 8 changed the events that are raised when a page is moved, and the redirect tracker doesn't handle the change. It's in the issue tracker here.

    Copy Link
  • bengan 26 posts 90 karma points
    Oct 16, 2019 @ 14:55
    bengan
    0

    Hi Steve, thanks for your quick reply!

    I am a bit disappointed with myself, that I was not able to find the issue in the issue tracker. But glad that there will be a fix.

    One question: The solved issue #5050 (in V8.3) does not solve the issue on delete, does it? Does exist another issue for this already?

    Copy Link
  • Steve Megson 151 posts 1024 karma points MVP c-trib
    Oct 16, 2019 @ 15:59
    Steve Megson
    0

    Deleting seems to work OK for me, with redirect entries being deleted when the target node is deleted. I wouldn't expect an entry to be created when a node is moved to the recycle bin, because we don't have a new URL to redirect to.

    There is perhaps some slightly odd behaviour while the target page is in the recycle bin, if there's an older redirect entry for a URL:

    • Create a page at /test/, rename it to /test-1/
    • /test/ correctly redirects to /test-1/
    • Create another page at /test/, rename it to /test-2/
    • /test/ correctly redirects to /test-2/
    • Delete /test-2/, and /test/ will be a 404. We find the redirect rule for the deleted node, but can't use it.
    • Empty the recycle bin, and /test/ starts to redirect to /test-1/ again. With the /test-2/ rule deleted, we find the older rule again.
    Copy Link
Please Sign in or register to post replies

Write your reply to:

Draft