Looks like it is the same issue that Jeff ran into here:

http://our.umbraco.org/projects/collaboration/uforum-basics/bugs/14137-NicePostingUrl-and-UseDirectoryUrls

It's a known bug. You could probably work around it for now to get it up and running, by editing the xslt. Let me know if you need the specific code.

I do need the code because I don't know what the hell I'm doing..:-)

If it is the same issue, you can replace uForum:NicePostingUrl($currentPage/@id) in the xslt with concat(umbraco.library.NiceUrl($currentPage/@id),'/ufForumNewTopic'). Haven't tried it, but should work.

That should be:

concat(umbraco.library.NiceUrl($currentPage/@id),'/ufNewTopic')

What xslt should I edit because I can't find that line in uForum-CommentsList.xslt

it should be the TopicList xslt file

ok.. so I changed

<a href="{uForum:NicePostingUrl($currentPage/@id)}">Create a new topic</a>

to

<a href="{concat(umbraco.library.NiceUrl($currentPage/@id),'/ufNewTopic')}">Create a new topic</a>

Is that correct or did I do it wrorng because I get errors

Needs to be umbraco.library:NiceUrl(....

Notice the colon instead of period.

Thanks.. That worked. Do you have any recommendations or are there any extentions to uForum to make it close to what Umbraco has?

You mean to get at look/feel like the our.umbraco.org site? There is currently quite a difference between the two. At CG10, there was some talk of releasing the code fore everyone to use, but has not happened yet.

is working on a reply...